The New York Academy Of Medicine
2003
David E. Rogers Fellowship
Summary
of Final Reports
Bebell, Lisa Marie and Douglas B. Berger
College
of Physicians and Surgeons, Columbia University
An Epidemiological and Community-Based Approach to Maternal-Newborn
HIV Infection in La Romana, Dominican
Republic
HIV is
perceived to be a significant problem in the Dominican Republic province of La Romana, though data on the rate of HIV infection is limited. There are also
few resources for care and treatment of those infected, and little centralized
planning aimed at reducing the spread of HIV. Ms. Bebell’s and Mr. Berger’s study
focused on the subset of pregnant women in La Romana, and was carried out in
conjunction with Family AIDS International (FAI), which is establishing in La
Romana the first family-based HIV care center in the Dominican Republic. Their
work had two aims: to help determine the prevalence of HIV in women of
childbearing age, and to help strengthen relationships among the major
obstetrical care centers in La Romana. The were engaged in clinical activities
at a variety of hospitals and clinics, and helped FAI expand from four to seven
the number of sites where FAI is collecting blood samples from mothers at the
time of birth, and also helped increase the standardization of sample
collection and data recording. “I feel that I absorbed much cultural knowledge
that is applicable to the Dominican community in which I live and work: Washington Heights,” Ms. Bebell writes. “These realizations will help me
treat patients with HIV and AIDS better, and understand the cultural isolation
they may be experiencing as a result of their disease. I also bring back
strengthened interest in practicing medicine in international contexts and,
regardless of location, in a way that engages whole communities.”
Burkey, Matthew David
Johns Hopkins School of Medicine
Narratives of Recovery Project
Matthew
Burkey’s Rogers Fellowship allowed him to study and explore the role of social
relationships in recovery by members of a homeless substance abusing
population—aimed especially at understanding the social factors affecting the
health of homeless individuals. This study of the perceptions of homeless men
towards their own recovery is a subject not previously studied in this
population. As part of the project, he carried out a number of in-depth
interviews with residents at a drug treatment facility in South Baltimore. Employing a qualitative research method, he began
with a focus of inquiry, explored this among a sample population, refined the
focus and returned to the field to explore the refined focus in greater depth.
His findings on the role of family, recovery networks, and outside
relationships should provide health practitioners with greater insight in
tailoring treatment to an individual’s needs, helping them understand which
relationships are generally positive and serve as resources in the recovery,
and which are generally negative and serve to deter the patient from treatment
goals. In this way, social ties will be better leveraged in the treatment of
addiction. Writes Mr. Burkey: “In the residents (of the treatment facility) I
found teachers. They shared hard-earned wisdom that is nowhere to be found in
the pages of pathology texts or within the walls of biochemistry laboratories.
Through these interactions, I was reminded of my original intent to pursue
medicine as a career. As I have begun the second year of my medical education,
I have experienced a renewed excitement for learning.”
Delgado, Mucio Christopher
College
of Physicians and Surgeons, Columbia University
Gaining Trust and Participation in Clinical Research
Among Hispanics: Study of Patient and Provider Experiences in AIDS and
Gastroenterology Clinical Trials in Puerto Rico
Hispanics
in the United
States,
including Puerto Ricans, are underrepresented in clinical research. Among the
strategies proposed to remedy this situation have been to develop more
“culturally competent” recruiting and retention strategies and to increase the
number of minority investigators in research. Mr. Delgado’s study examined
factors that may affect participation in research in Puerto Rico where investigators and research participants share a cultural
background. He conducted a cross-sectional survey of 101 Hispanics in San Juan on such subjects as HIV, gastroenterology and general
care. He found that the factors that are important to individuals in deciding
whether to participate in research included effective written communication
between them and researchers, personal contact with study investigator,
referral by a specialist, and access to free counseling and medical treatment.
Monetary incentives, media advertisements, hired patient recruiters and
community partnerships, however, were shown to have little to no effect on
willingness to participate. Mr. Delgado believes that a comparative study is
now warranted in the United States. “My experience has given me tremendous insight into
my career path. . . . I learned more this summer than I did in my first year at
Columbia, and contributed to my interests in pursuing health
disparities research and advocacy in the future. I have decided (to) pursue an
M.P.H. between my third and fourth year to develop extra skills in epidemiology
and statistics. Without the funding from the Rogers fellowship, none of this would have been possible.”
Drain, Paul Kevin
School of Medicine, University of Washington
Selenium Supplementation and Genital Tract Shedding of
HIV-1 Among Women in Kenya
Vitamin
deficiencies have been associated with HIV-1 infection, more rapid disease
progression and AIDS-related mortality, while micronutrient supplementation has
been associated with delayed progression to AIDS and improved survival.
Micronutrient supplementation thus could offer a simple and relatively
inexpensive strategy to slow HIV-1 progression, either alone or as a complement
to antiretroviral therapy. Several studies have suggested that serum selenium
is associated with HIV-1 disease status, but this relationship has not been
fully characterized. Mr. Drain’s study sought to determine whether serum
selenium was independently associated with CD4 cell count or plasma viral load.
The study involved a cross-sectional analysis using baseline data from 400
HIV-1 seropositive women of low socioeconomic status who were enrolled in a
randomized trial of micronutrient supplementation at Coast Provincial
General Hospital in Mombasa, Kenya. Results demonstrate that serum selenium is
independently associated with serum albumin but not with CD4 count or plasma
viral load, and suggest that decreases in serum selenium among HIV-infected
patients may simply reflect decreases in serum albumin that occur in advanced
HIV-1 disease. Although serum selenium may not accurately reflect total body
selenium status, measurement of serum selenium should be interpreted in the
context of the serum albumin concentration. In the absence of an independent
association between serum selenium and CD4 count or plasma viral load, it seems
unlikely that selenium supplementation would have a substantial impact on HIV-1
disease progression. “My summer research experience in Kenya has had a very positive effect on shaping my future
medical career in public health and international health, “writes Mr. Drain.
“It has encouraged me to continue exploring international health opportunities.
At this early stage in my medical training, I am interested in pursuing a
career in international health that allows me to practice medicine and conduct
research of public health importance. My experience in Kenya further strengthened those goals.”
Goldberg, Joshua Benjamin
Albert Einstein College of Medicine
Factors Contributing to Breast Cancer Treatment
Adherence: Socio-Economic Status versus Race/Ethnicity
Lack of
adherence to cancer treatment regimens has long been recognized by the medical
community as a major problem but, surprisingly, there has been little research
into the barriers that patients experience. While many cancer treatments have
been shown to improve patients’ prognosis and quality of life, patients
continually fail to complete their treatment regimen. One of the major
demographic variables that has been shown to influence
adherence among cancer patients is race and ethnicity. However, the recent
literature has indicated that associating adherence with race/ethnicity is an
inaccurate conclusion. Rather, it has been proposed that disparities in
adherence are largely a function of patients’ socioeconomic status with
race/ethnicity playing a secondary role. Mr. Goldberg’s Rogers Fellowship
enabled him to participate in a major study focusing on the relative influence
of socioeconomic status versus race/ethnicity in contributing to patients’
adherence. He joined the research team in the early stages of the project and
had an active role in the design and early implementation of this ongoing study
focusing on African-American women and Caucasian women who are recently
diagnosed with breast cancer. “In addition to learning about the various
psychosocial parameters, constructing questionnaires and interviews, I gained
valuable experience in the intricacies of organizing a multi-center research
project. . . . Through the numerous meetings and communications with
administrators, physicians, nurses, and social workers I was able to gain
insight into the particular needs and desires of each group with regard to
research and learn how to get all to work as a team. Prior to this Fellowship I
was naïve to this aspect of research and assumed that the development of a hypothesis,
appropriate measures and subjects were the primary focus of research. This
lesson will prove valuable not only in my future research, but in my clinical
practice as well.”
Goodrich, Suzanne Porter
Indiana University School of Medicine
SHARE: A Study of HIV/AIDS Related Education
In 2002
the World Health Organization reported that more than 42 million people
worldwide were infected with HIV and that 3.1 million people had died of AIDS
that year. The needed response to such a health crisis should address the
contributing social, political, economic and health factors. The instruction
given during the training of physicians related to HIV/AIDS must be
comprehensive and effective and fully enable them to treat their own patients
and to contribute meaningfully to local and global efforts to control the HIV
pandemic. In her Rogers Fellowship, Ms. Goodrich conducted a research project
that looked specifically at the HIV/AIDS curricula presented to students in the
basic science and clinical years at two medical schools—in Indiana and in Kenya. She found that the role HIV/AIDS plays in the
curricula of the two schools is quite different. In Africa,
the study of HIV/AIDS takes a predominant role, especially in the clinical
years, due to its prevalence. In Indiana, the role of HIV/AIDS instruction is well defined in
the basic science years, but due to low disease prevalence it has a
proportionately small role in the clinical years. Ms. Goodrich is continuing to
work with her Kenyan colleague and counterpart, a fifth year medical student,
to complete the review of transcripts from all the interviews and focus groups
that were conducted at both universities and to finish identifying the unifying
themes, with the intention of submitting her research to a journal after its
completion, as a great amount of interest was generated among the faculty and
administration at both schools during the interviewing process and many
requests to review the results of the research have been received. “The award
has generously allowed me to pursue an aspect of one of my greatest areas of
interest in healthcare. . . . My project has not only given me insight into two
different curricula related to HIV/AIDS, but I have [also] gained a better
understanding of how curricula is planned, organized and delivered at the
medical school level. I believe as physicians that we must constantly work to
improve our work through both novel research and critical assessment of our
practices. I am grateful for the opportunity so early in my medical career to
contribute to the knowledge we have about best practices in medicine.”
Huang, Angela Chia-Mei
Brody School of Medicine at East Carolina University
An Investigation of Caregiver Stress in Parents of
Severely Emotional Disturbed Children Enrolled in a Public Residential
Treatment Program Using Participatory Action Research
Family
involvement has been regarded as an integral component of the care of children
with serious emotional problems. In the course of her Rogers Fellowship, Ms.
Huang worked at Eastern Area Residential Treatment Home (EARTH), a five-day residential treatment facility in eastern North Carolina for children ages 5-12 with severe emotional and
behavioral problems. She attended individual, group and family therapy sessions
to learn about the ways in which family involvement is integrated into care. To
integrate the role of family members as
evaluators and researchers, she conducted research with caregivers of
children at EARTH using Photovoice, a participatory action research method
involving photographs and discussion, to specifically evaluate the stressors
and strengths facing these families. The stressors she identified were mainly
within the individual or intrapersonal level and included family, grandparents’
raising children after having raised their own children, and concerns by the
caregivers about their own health. Some strengths
identified included: self-defined “comforts,” support from family and friends,
and the joy derived from the children themselves. The project succeeded in empowering
these families to be active partners in research: the families decided as a
result of their participation to revive parent group meetings at EARTH to
increase social support and to provide information for new families enrolling
children to increase awareness of the importance of stressors and strengths.
Writes Ms. Huang: “My summer experience allowed me to see the side of medicine
that, as physicians, we may never have time to see . . . it challenged my
immediate notions of childhood, families, and the way people live. It taught me
not to assume anything. Children with behavioral and emotional disability look
like any other children, but they are distinctly different. They act
differently, have different needs, and must be treated differently. Families
were not composed of a traditional mother and a father unit, but of
grandparents, single mothers, aunts and uncles, and family networks. This
experience showed me how to focus on a family’s strengths and not to be
distracted by weaknesses even in the worst circumstances. In some families, it
was difficult to find the strengths, but working with these children and
especially these families, inspired me.”
Kalil, Dominique
University
of Texas Health Science Center at San Antonio
Food, Culture and Genetics: A Study of Adolescent
Obesity in San Antonio, Texas
An estimated 58 million American adults qualify today
as either overweight or obese, and diet and sedentary lifestyles contribute to
300,000 preventable deaths each year. Obesity is now also a pediatric illness
of epidemic proportions, as an estimated three-quarters of children
born to obese parents will be overweight. Pediatric obese patients also appear
to have reduced immune function, suggesting that obesity makes the body
susceptible to a host of illnesses against which it would usually be able to
defend itself, and in the last two decades hospital costs associated with
obesity diagnosis among youths aged 6 to 17 have risen from $35 million to $127
million. Obesity is especially prevalent in San Antonio, Texas—recently
crowned “America’s fattest
city.” While national figures put overweight or obese adults at about 30
percent, 61 percent of Texas adults today
are overweight or obese. In her Rogers Fellowship, Ms. Khalil sought to
understand why this is so by evaluating the health implications of pediatric
obesity and the Texas state
government response. Obese
children typically come from lower socioeconomic backgrounds, but in San Antonio very little research has been done within the
Hispanic community. Numerous studies have shown however that black and white
obese teenagers responded differently to the same treatment. Thus, the most
inappropriate treatment would account for ethnic and racial differences. School based programs have the potential to be most
effective in educating and treating adolescent obesity, and in many cases have
lived up to that potential. In 2001 the Texas
Medical Association lobbied for legislation that increased physical activity
for school aged children, but as an unfunded mandate without enforceable
punishment, schools have failed to follow its guidelines. “Fighting obesity is
going to take years,” writes Ms. Khalil, “and to most of the physicians I
consulted, will be a problem for decades to come. There are neither quick fixes
nor sure solutions, but essentially more funding needs to be directed towards
pharmacotherapy and higher taxes imposed on fatty, densely caloric food. Those
most vulnerable to obesity need to be targeted by public health campaigns and
healthy eating needs to become as common place as safe sex.”
Liu, Constance Wei-fang
Case Western Reserve University
Food Environment Described by Measures of Healthy Food
Selection
A 1997 USDA literature review concluded that
low-income households spend less money in supermarkets as opposed to other
types of food markets and are less likely to be located in suburban locations
where prices are typically lower. Thus, those low-income households that are
severely limited by the type and availability of stores are faced as well with
significantly higher food costs. Quality furthermore tends to be lower for
lower-income households. Ms. Liu’s research served as a pilot project to
examine the food environment in Cleveland, Ohio using a developed measure
of healthy food selection. Although several recent studies have examined the
interaction between environment and people’s relative health, her research
filled a void in the literature regarding the relationship between people and
their food environment. The aim of the study was to describe the food
environment and its association with Cleveland’s neighborhood
characteristics. In addition to describing the prevalence of food stores, she
sought to find a measure describing the relative healthiness of the selection
of foods available. In designing her study, she determined that the amount of
shelf space devoted to fruits and vegetables would serve as an indicator of the
relative healthiness of food environment, as prior research shows that food
disparities are most evident in the consumption of fresh fruits and vegetables.
Ms. Liu found that large, national chain stores had more than three times as
much shelf space devoted to fruits and vegetables as independent stores, and
her work will serve as a useful exploratory study that will inform a larger
study of the food environment of Cleveland, and for future expansion of
research inquiry to include examination of how people interact with their
environment. “Through this experience, I came to understand Cleveland in pursuing this
relatively unexplored area of research. I have learned not only valuable
statistical tools and techniques but also the difficulties of managing even a
relatively small database. I believe that it is by understanding the
relationship of people to their environment that I can best serve the
community, and that as a physician I can come to identify the important
research questions and, as a future researcher, answer those questions.”
Loiselle, Christopher R.
Johns Hopkins School of Medicine
Psychological Determinants of Tuberculosis
Susceptibility
Tuberculosis
is a disease that causes 3 million deaths per year worldwide. While it is
uncommon in the developed world, it remains a problem in countries of the
developing world like Peru, where incidence is similar to levels in Europe
and North America in the 19th century: 200-400 cases per
100,000 people. TB is currently one of the most frequent infectious causes of
death worldwide and both TB prevalence and mortality are increasing in most
countries. While TB is a disease of great world significance, contributing
psychosocial factors are far less well understood than psychological
associations to disease in the western world, like that of the evidence linking
stress with major diseases like cardiovascular disease and cancer. For his
Fellowship, Mr. Loiselle worked with the non-governmental organization
Asociación Benéfica Prisma in Lima,
Peru to characterize stress, depression, and anxiety in a
shantytown population, and to begin to examine whether these psychosocial
characteristics are determinants of TB susceptibility. The aim of his study was
to identify psychosocial symptoms that may be risk factors for TB infection.
Knowing whether factors such as stress, depression, and anxiety play a role in
developing symptomatic TB infection may contribute to a novel strategy for
identifying individuals at the greatest risk for developing TB, who may then
receive screening and preventative interventions. This study documented
considerable prevalence of stress, depression, and anxiety among TB patients
and their household contacts, with significantly higher rates of depression
among women than men. How to help individuals with depression is a key question
that needs to be answered before longitudinal studies can continue. Individuals
suffering from depression in this community may be receptive to group
interpersonal psychotherapy for depression. Psychiatrists collaborating with
the study in Peru are visiting with TB patients and their household
contacts who have high scores in depression scales in
their homes for a formal psychiatric interview, education about depression, and
an explanation about realistic treatment options; however, more sustainable,
community oriented and long term interactions are necessary to truly improve
the situation.
Moon, Byung Joon
New York Medical College
AIDS Prevention Program Proposal: Assessment of
Clinical and Cultural Boundaries in AIDS/HIV Treatment and Prevention in South Korea
Mr.
Moon’s project investigated aspects of cultural and socio-economic conditions
unique to Korea that appear to serve as obstacles in preventing
AIDS/HIV infection. The goal of his study was to clarify and describe which of
these obstacles seem most to impede HIV prevention there
and his theory was that South Korea’s relatively conservative cultural atmosphere serves
as a major deterring factor. In carrying out his research, Mr. Moon worked in a
hospital with the guidance of his mentor. He designed and conducted patient
interviews, made outpatient clinic visits and talked to residents, and observed
any biomedical research that was being done on AIDS/HIV. Other sources of
information for his research were the Internet, and visits to support centers
for HIV/AIDS patients. He also conducted research into South Korea’s national formal education system and its policy on
sex education. He discovered that among the general public, most people
professed little knowledge about the disease. The vast majority associated it
with sexual promiscuity and unorthodox approaches to sex in general. Some
expressed the belief that the disease is a punishment based on religious
beliefs—chiefly Buddhism, Christianity and Catholicism. Most people felt that
western influence infiltrating Korea brought about these diseases, and some held the
advancing influence of Japanese culture responsible. Writes Mr. Moon: “This
eye-opening experience made me realize how one disease in one unique
socio-economic and cultural setting can differ to another. Spending time in
Korea doing research on this topic made me realize that its leaders need to
address this issue and that more resources should be put into education,
awareness and prevention, and establishing more support networks so that AIDS
patients may receive the guidance that they need and seek.”
Scott,
Randolph D.
Brody School of Medicine at East Carolina University
JEWEL: Juniors Educated With an Empowering Lifestyle
Data
published in 2001 by the North Carolina Department of Health and Human Services
states that North Carolinian minority males are ten times more likely to die
from AIDS than white males, and that minority females are thirty-six times more
likely to die from AIDS than white females. The conception and implementation
of Mr. Scott’s research project, Juniors Educated With an Empowering Lifestyle
(JEWEL), were inspired by the fact that fully 96 percent of adolescent HIV
transmissions are due to sexual activity and intravenous drug use; by the
prevalence and incidence of HIV in the African American community; and by his
desire to become proactive in helping educate at-risk young people in North
Carolina about HIV transmission and prevention. He designed JEWEL to be a
comprehensive summer program incorporating HIV education, participant volunteer
activities and participant presentations. Through “Act SMART,” an American Red
Cross curriculum that assists teens in resisting premature sexual activity, he
taught his students how to handle peer pressure. A community service activity
at the Pitt County AIDS Service Organization enabled his students to apply
classroom learning to real life outcomes. Participant presentations were based
upon information gathered in books, in journals and on the Internet. Writes Mr.
Scott: “I am inspired to be more persistent and diligent in my pursuit of becoming
a physician who is involved in the community. Due to the lessons I have
learned, I will reach back to help those who are having difficulty helping
themselves. . . .I can’t say it enough: thank you for this opportunity.”
Shirk, Arianna McLain
Wake Forest University School of Medicine: Bowman Gray Campus
Attitudes and Training of Healthcare Providers in
Relation to Screening to Identify Women Who Have Experienced Intimate Partner
Violence
An
estimated three million women suffer injury as a result of intimate partner
violence each year. Healthcare workers are uniquely positioned to slow the
cycle of abuse before it reaches life threatening extremes through consistent
screening and educated intervention. Ms. Shirk’s study sought to identify
behaviors and attitudes of healthcare workers in North Carolina about screening
for intimate partner violence—and was unique in its attempt to acquire
information about the attitudes and behaviors of the entire primary care
healthcare workforce in a restricted area. A survey questionnaire was developed
and utilized and from the results, several observations were made about the
attitudes and behaviors of Forsyth County healthcare workers. In regard to universal screening,
the study revealed two statistically significant differences in attitudes of
healthcare workers, but their practices in the event of a positive screening
varied significantly in nine of twelve of the behaviors addressed in the
survey. The most important variable was their day-to-day comfort level and confidence
in their training. In previous studies, gender had been noted as a significant
factor affecting universal screening practices and general attitudes and
behaviors in regard to intimate partner violence. However, the current study
showed no significance differences in male and female attitudes. Some results
were similar to those reported by other studies, but others may indicate
changing trends in healthcare workers’ approach to women in their practices.
Hopefully, the results of this study and others like it will lead to more
geographically specific interventions to more effectively intervene. Writes Ms.
Shirk: “Practically, I learned the steps that are necessary to prepare for
publishing a coherent, relevant and understandable paper. I learned the basics
of medical research and gained skills that I will use repeatedly in the future.
On a more personal level . . . I learned that my awareness and understanding of
patients could be as impacted by my training as by my personal beliefs. As far
as future endeavors, I want to continue research in the field of intimate
partner violence and women’s health. . . . Hopefully, my initial endeavor into
academic and social medicine will lead to a more in-depth expansion of these
social truths I have begun to explore.”
Shue, Peter Lee
New York University School of Medicine
Prevalence of GBV-C Viremia in the HIV-Infected
Pediatric Population of New York City and It's Association in Improving Mortality
The GB Virus type C (GBV-C) is a
positive single-strand RNA virus that has been classified as a member of the
flaviridae family. GBV-C and hepatitis G virus (HGV) are two variant strains of
the same virus. Recent studies on GBV-C co-infection in HIV infected adults
have suggested a beneficial interaction between the two viruses. These studies
have demonstrated that GBV-C viremia is associated with lower HIV viral loads
and higher CD4 counts, and slowing progression toward AIDS. This has important
implications in the clinical and therapeutic management of HIV as the prevalence
of GBV-C viremia is relatively high (17–41 percent) among HIV patients, given
that the mode of transmission is similar. Despite the seroprevalence studies in
adults and the promising data on GBV-C as a possible therapeutic agent against
HIV, there is a lack of data on the prevalence or effect of GBV-C infection in
HIV-infected children. Given that GBV-C infection is high among HIV infected
mothers and that vertical transmission rate is high, a high prevalence of GBV-C
infection can be expected in HIV infected children. In his study, Mr. Shue
investigated the prevalence of GBV-C infection in a cohort of 103 HIV-infected
children and 88 children who seroreverted to HIV, and
the differences in GBV-C viral load among mothers and infants and whether
vertical transmission of GBV-C is correlated with maternal viral load at time
of delivery. The study demonstrated that 33 percent of children born to GBV-C
mothers acquired the infection. Previous epidemiological studies have suggested
that mothers having higher GBV-C titers were more likely to transmit to their
infants. Mr. Shue’s study did not find this correlation between maternal GBV-C
viral load and rate of vertical transmission. This discrepancy may be due to
the difference in study population since mothers in his study were co-infected
with HIV. There may be an unidentified interaction between the two viruses that
can affect vertical transmission of GBV-C. Writes Mr. Shue: “Not only did I
learn a great deal about the pathology of HIV [through my fellowship], but I
also learned more about its effects on society. I gained a greater
understanding to the many hardships that HIV has placed on the pediatric
population, especially those in underserved communities. With this
understanding, I hope to better serve the community through education and
prevention when I begin my practice. I truly thank The New York Academy of
Medicine for sponsoring this incredible fellowship and giving students like
myself an opportunity to explore medicine.”
Spector, Andrew Robert
University of Michigan
Assisting Alcoholics in their Quest to Quit Smoking
Mr.
Spector’s fellowship entailed designing and administering a smoking cessation
program focused on members of the homeless population,
chosen because of the obvious benefits to them as well as for the fact that the
costliness of participation in smoking cessation therapy precludes their taking
advantage of it. Mr. Spector’s study design called for research subjects to
take part in nine cognitive-behavioral therapy sessions administered by trained
medical students between their first and second years of medical school. Writes
Mr. Spector: “The experience of designing a study from the bottom up has taught
me a great deal about the research process, but I consider the two most
important things I will take from this summer to be my training in
cognitive-behavioral therapy with the accompanying insight into the psyche of
an addict. The training program allowed me to observe each of these programs
and integrate myself into the therapy sessions. I received hands-on training in
cognitive-behavioral therapy while simultaneously interacting with the patients
to learn their perspectives on the treatments. The most salient observation I
made is that medical students are severely underprepared to serve (the
homeless) population. Aside from what I learned from [my mentor] academically,
I also gained career perspective. . . . I realize [now] it was premature to
direct my education toward exclusively clinical goals. Through this experience,
my eyes have been opened to the plight of addicts, the field of addiction
psychiatry and the blending of research and clinical careers. I have also
learned more about cognitive-behavioral therapy than I imagine could ever be
possible in medical school.”
Turek, Eva Margo
College
of Physicians and Surgeons, Columbia University
HIV-Positive Pregnant Women at CEMI and Adherence to
HAART
In 1986,
in response to the realization that many HIV infected pregnant women were
neither screened for the virus during their visits to their physicians nor
monitored post-partum, Dr. Carmen Zorrilla founded the Maternal-Infant Studies
Center (with the Spanish acronym of CEMI) in Puerto Rico. By providing
education, psychological support, and counseling to HIV-positive pregnant women
in addition to antiretroviral therapy, CEMI has been extremely successful in
preventing mother-to-child transmission of the virus. The perinatal HIV
transmission rate for the pregnant women receiving care at CEMI has been zero
since September 1996. A more recent article awaiting publication reports on the
good adherence rates reported by CEMI’s pregnant women as compared to the non-pregnant
cohort receiving HAART (Highly Active Anti-Retroviral Therapy) —92 percent vs.
70 percent. Ms. Turek devoted her Rogers Fellowship to a more in-depth
exploration of the factors related to good adherence, and discovered that the
adherence rate among non-pregnant HIV positive participants was 90 percent—a
significant increase from previously cited figures. In her study, she
interviewed a group of women attending CEMI. Of thirty non-pregnant women,
twenty-seven demonstrated complete adherence to their medications. In an effort
to understand why the participants in this survey take their medications (or
what would serve as motivation for improvement in adherence), Ms. Turek asked
them to rank their main motivators. Nearly 58 percent claimed internal motivation
such as the desire to prolong one’s life, to maintain one’s health and to feel
better in comparison to 42 percent who claimed external motivation such as
one’s children, one’s partner, one’s family or the desire to reduce HIV
transmission to one’s future baby. This Ms. Turek characterizes as the most
interesting finding from her small sample—the seeming relationship between
motivation and viral suppression. Her data suggests some connection does exist
between viral load (the measure of the outcome of adherence) and motivational
factors. “A finding such as this generates new questions and opens new doors
for future exploration,” writes Ms. Turek. “I feel both personally and
professionally satisfied with my experience in Puerto Rico. I gained a better understanding of the values of doing research in a
clinical setting. Another important lesson I learned from this experience is
the importance of adherence and the many different ways in which it can be
measured. . . . I will forever be sensitive to the issues that (affect) the
women at CEMI . . . the realities I faced this summer are empowering because I
now have an understanding of treatment that I can take with me in my future as
a physician.”
###